We all enter movie theatres with expectations. Most of us have seen enough films to have a favourite genre that we’d be least likely to regret being $17 poorer for. The truth behind it all is that a genre only exists if people respond to it, and hardly anyone can doubt the existence of the science fiction film and the romantic comedy. Both genres take aspects of life and wrap them up in fantasy, whether that involves journeying to the ends of the universe or diving into the depths of the human heart. The question is: which version of unreality should we validate with our patronage?
Movie tickets and DVDs have standard prices, so there’s no point arguing about which genre is cheaper to watch, right? Not necessarily. Sci fi films often have sequels, which means we pay to complete these trilogies and quadrillogies. They’re also much more likely to have merchandise. Think Star Wars Lego, drinks, music CDs, what-have-you. While the basic costs are the same, romantic comedies don’t have associated costs, so we end up spending more money if we get into sci fi. (And that’s not even counting the cost of being labelled as a geek.)
Still, there’s a reason why we’re willing to pay so much. The appeal of sci fi lies in its special effects, so its appearance has improved with the improvement of technology. By contrast, romantic comedies haven’t changed in appearance much at all over time. These movies hardly ever construct their own worlds, contain extraterrestrial creatures or have widespread destruction in them, so they don’t dazzle anyone with effects. What they lack in effects, however, they make up for in eye candy. They have attractive actors and actresses who smile a lot, and I guess that’s more than enough to dazzle some people.
When it comes to plot structure, romantic comedies thrive on the familiar. We turn up to the rom com knowing that in spite of the circumstances and people that threaten to keep them apart, the man and the woman on that glossy movie poster will live happily ever after. That might just be the peak of cliché, but cliché is precisely the backbone of this genre. Countless Hollywood romantic comedies just depict variations of two classic love stories: falling for someone completely unlikely, often someone you once despised, as in Ten Things I Hate About You and The Proposal, and falling for the “friend” who’s always been there, as in When Harry Met Sally and Win a Date With Tad Hamilton.
That being said, sci fi doesn’t escape conventions either. Technology gets out of hand in films such as 2001: A Space Odyssey and The Matrix and evil aliens are defeated in Alien and MIB. There is often an attempt to find The Chosen One, whether that is Neo, a certain Skywalker or John Connor. In stretching our definitions of time and space, though, sci fi films are much more capable of twists and surprises along the way, making for a more complex and less predictable plot.
Nevertheless, plot isn’t everything. A movie must be watchable. In line with their themes, sci fi films are bound to be more violent or disgusting or both. For instance, no one can forget the baby alien breaking out of the man’s chest cavity in Alien. Sci fi can force us to close our eyes or at least squirm in our seats, whether we’re predisposed to enjoy it or not. Then again, romantic comedy films are known for their mawkish lines, some of which are just as good at making people cringe. A case in point is Win a Date With Tad Hamilton’s Pete knowing that Rosalie has six different smiles. There’s sweet, and then there’s overdoing it. It just depends on whether someone can appreciate blood and guts more than corny lines and sappy background music, or vice versa.
But for all its entertainment value and all our varied reactions to sci fi, its function is hard to pin down. These films do amaze, but that’s not all. The genre uses fantasy to comment on reality and hint at where humanity might be headed. 2001 warns against our reliance on technology, and Minority Report alerts us to the amount of power we surrender to the government and police. What really sets this genre apart is that it is not only loved by its target audience, it is also thought about a fair bit, and once you start thinking too much about what you consume, you become a geek, removed from pop culture. In a way, that makes sense; you’d have to be somewhat removed from society to understand the bigger picture, which sci fi tackles. Besides, aren’t geeks also stereotypically the ones who know more than most others?
On the other hand, romantic comedies have a clear target audience and a simple function. Let’s face it; the only substance a rom com can hope to have is some insight into human nature. They’re out there to make us laugh if they can, but there is always a sense that it is a love story first and only a comedy second. Rom coms try to make people feel good. They’re cheesy enough for giddy 14-year-old girls and hopeless romantics who at least want to believe in love as these films define it, but the said cheesiness can, and does, backfire. The relationships in most rom coms are actually contradictory: they clump the infatuation and grand gestures that characterise early relationships with the emotional depth that is typical only of relationships that have lasted much longer. These idealistic representations of love seem realistic because of the believable setting. Even He’s Just Not That Into You, the movie in which a man, Alex, attempts to tell a friend, Gigi, that flowery love stories are merely exceptions to the norm, reverts to this mentality in the end when Alex declares that Gigi is his exception. Thanks to rom coms, many viewers, especially teenagers, get the wrong idea about love and feel disappointed when their lives don’t match the wonderful things they see on screen. Girls today, to borrow a line from Sleepless in Seattle, “don’t want to fall in love. [They] want to fall in love in a movie.”
It’s clear that a lot goes into our enjoyment of science fiction and romantic comedies. It can be granted that both genres make claims that probably aren’t all that realistic or sound, and it might also be granted that it is this fantasy factor that draws us most to them. It all comes down to taste and there’s certainly no law against appreciating both, but rom coms definitely need at least one thing that sci fi has: a “Part of this is fiction” disclaimer.
Movie tickets and DVDs have standard prices, so there’s no point arguing about which genre is cheaper to watch, right? Not necessarily. Sci fi films often have sequels, which means we pay to complete these trilogies and quadrillogies. They’re also much more likely to have merchandise. Think Star Wars Lego, drinks, music CDs, what-have-you. While the basic costs are the same, romantic comedies don’t have associated costs, so we end up spending more money if we get into sci fi. (And that’s not even counting the cost of being labelled as a geek.)
Still, there’s a reason why we’re willing to pay so much. The appeal of sci fi lies in its special effects, so its appearance has improved with the improvement of technology. By contrast, romantic comedies haven’t changed in appearance much at all over time. These movies hardly ever construct their own worlds, contain extraterrestrial creatures or have widespread destruction in them, so they don’t dazzle anyone with effects. What they lack in effects, however, they make up for in eye candy. They have attractive actors and actresses who smile a lot, and I guess that’s more than enough to dazzle some people.
When it comes to plot structure, romantic comedies thrive on the familiar. We turn up to the rom com knowing that in spite of the circumstances and people that threaten to keep them apart, the man and the woman on that glossy movie poster will live happily ever after. That might just be the peak of cliché, but cliché is precisely the backbone of this genre. Countless Hollywood romantic comedies just depict variations of two classic love stories: falling for someone completely unlikely, often someone you once despised, as in Ten Things I Hate About You and The Proposal, and falling for the “friend” who’s always been there, as in When Harry Met Sally and Win a Date With Tad Hamilton.
That being said, sci fi doesn’t escape conventions either. Technology gets out of hand in films such as 2001: A Space Odyssey and The Matrix and evil aliens are defeated in Alien and MIB. There is often an attempt to find The Chosen One, whether that is Neo, a certain Skywalker or John Connor. In stretching our definitions of time and space, though, sci fi films are much more capable of twists and surprises along the way, making for a more complex and less predictable plot.
Nevertheless, plot isn’t everything. A movie must be watchable. In line with their themes, sci fi films are bound to be more violent or disgusting or both. For instance, no one can forget the baby alien breaking out of the man’s chest cavity in Alien. Sci fi can force us to close our eyes or at least squirm in our seats, whether we’re predisposed to enjoy it or not. Then again, romantic comedy films are known for their mawkish lines, some of which are just as good at making people cringe. A case in point is Win a Date With Tad Hamilton’s Pete knowing that Rosalie has six different smiles. There’s sweet, and then there’s overdoing it. It just depends on whether someone can appreciate blood and guts more than corny lines and sappy background music, or vice versa.
But for all its entertainment value and all our varied reactions to sci fi, its function is hard to pin down. These films do amaze, but that’s not all. The genre uses fantasy to comment on reality and hint at where humanity might be headed. 2001 warns against our reliance on technology, and Minority Report alerts us to the amount of power we surrender to the government and police. What really sets this genre apart is that it is not only loved by its target audience, it is also thought about a fair bit, and once you start thinking too much about what you consume, you become a geek, removed from pop culture. In a way, that makes sense; you’d have to be somewhat removed from society to understand the bigger picture, which sci fi tackles. Besides, aren’t geeks also stereotypically the ones who know more than most others?
On the other hand, romantic comedies have a clear target audience and a simple function. Let’s face it; the only substance a rom com can hope to have is some insight into human nature. They’re out there to make us laugh if they can, but there is always a sense that it is a love story first and only a comedy second. Rom coms try to make people feel good. They’re cheesy enough for giddy 14-year-old girls and hopeless romantics who at least want to believe in love as these films define it, but the said cheesiness can, and does, backfire. The relationships in most rom coms are actually contradictory: they clump the infatuation and grand gestures that characterise early relationships with the emotional depth that is typical only of relationships that have lasted much longer. These idealistic representations of love seem realistic because of the believable setting. Even He’s Just Not That Into You, the movie in which a man, Alex, attempts to tell a friend, Gigi, that flowery love stories are merely exceptions to the norm, reverts to this mentality in the end when Alex declares that Gigi is his exception. Thanks to rom coms, many viewers, especially teenagers, get the wrong idea about love and feel disappointed when their lives don’t match the wonderful things they see on screen. Girls today, to borrow a line from Sleepless in Seattle, “don’t want to fall in love. [They] want to fall in love in a movie.”
It’s clear that a lot goes into our enjoyment of science fiction and romantic comedies. It can be granted that both genres make claims that probably aren’t all that realistic or sound, and it might also be granted that it is this fantasy factor that draws us most to them. It all comes down to taste and there’s certainly no law against appreciating both, but rom coms definitely need at least one thing that sci fi has: a “Part of this is fiction” disclaimer.
Current Mood:
calm (before the storm?)
Current Music: Boys Like Girls - Love Drunk
Leave a comment

